Today's Challenge: Hard People Decisions – Part 1

One of the most challenging questions I repeatedly get from leaders is, not surprisingly, about people. Not just any people – the question is most often about an individual who hasn’t been able or willing to keep up with the demands of the job. These may be one of the thorniest situations a leader ever faces.

In many cases, the person isn’t willfully rejecting the challenge to get better – it’s a personal capacity issue. And, in the most difficult of these cases, the person has actually done good work in the past. To top it off, these men and women are often long-term, loyal members of the team. What do you do?
There is certainly no formula I’ve discovered for responding to these situations – I struggle with this too! However, there are some things we can do to make this challenge more approachable.
Give crystal clear expectations . I’ve actually seen people do a 180-degree turn when expectations are clarified – Shame on me for not making them clear from the beginning. Don’t assume people know what is expected – guarantee it.
Give people resources. If someone is struggling to fulfill their responsibilities, or to grow with the demands of the role, be sure they have the resources they need. Clearly, this is highly situational, but critical nonetheless. Do they need training? A mentor? Leaders provide resources.
Give people time. Don’t expect miracles regarding the cycle time on a turnaround. If someone is really struggling, be realistic. You may not see the changes you desire in days or weeks. It may take months. However, you can’t afford for these situations to go on forever; you’ll ultimately need the next idea.
Give the gift of accountability. No plan should be allowed to go on indefinitely. Set a goal – with deadlines. Monitor progress and talk candidly about the prospects for the future. Don’t let people live in denial and don’t let them be surprised if things don’t turn out like you both want them to.
Before we make a decision that will alter the life and career of an employee, we want to be sure we’ve done all we could to help him or her be successful. Truett Cathy, the founder of Chick-fil-A challenged me years ago by telling me you can’t build a career by terminating people – you want to build a reputation for helping people be successful. Although that’s always the goal, sometimes it will not be possible for them to be successful in your organization.
When you’ve done the items I’ve outlined here and the issue remains, I have five additional suggestions to help you make hard people decisions. More on that next week…[GLS_Shield]

Leave a comment



Dustin

8 years ago

This is one of the toughest challenges of managing people. I’ve found content from both Jim Collins and Dave Ramsey to be helpful in this area, but I’m looking forward to your follow up post next week!

mark

8 years ago

Thanks, Dustin! Let me know what you think after you read Friday’s post.

Sean

8 years ago

Thank you for showing the responsibility of the leader to pave the way to productivity. Too often people are promoted out of effectiveness and their superiors think the employee is suddenly inept. Your suggestions are powerful. Leaders need to see that they have done everything possible to provide success. Thank you as always Mark.

mark

8 years ago

Thanks, Sean for taking time to comment! I look forward to your feedback on Part 2 of the post – It will be out on Friday.

Five Blogs – 5 March 2013 | 5blogs

8 years ago

[…] Today’s Challenge: Hard People Decisions – Part 1 Written by: Mark Miller […]

My great Wordpress blog | Just another WordPress site | Today’s Challenge: Hard People Decisions – Part 2

6 years ago

[…] week, I began a post on Hard People Decisions. I wrote about specific things we can do to help someone who’s struggling to grow into the role. […]

My great Wordpress blog | Just another WordPress site | Today’s Challenge: What’s Your Question?

6 years ago

[…] How do you respond to poor performers? […]

Copyright © 2020. All rights reserved